The value of building a database and having a relationship with members cannot be overstated. Permission-based, opt-in members are the basis of marketing success and clearly the most active part of your target group. Still, many operators continue to place most of their marketing emphasis on the "shotgun" approach, directing their incentives to the entire pool of possible respondents, irrespective of the likelihood of turning them into a loyal customer and ignorant to the likelihood those people will affect their real success.
For radio stations, this manifests in many ways, including offering prizes to all listeners separately from the prizes in the rewards program.
While the intention in this strategy is understandable, there are a couple of fundamental flaws here.
First, there is no doubt that if a consumer can enjoy the benefits offered with or without becoming a member of your database, they will choose not to join. If you could get a free ticket on American Airlines without joining their Advantage program, the incentive to join is greatly lessened. If membership has no privilege, why be a member? American Express won't let me have any of their incentives unless I carry their credit card and use it!
Secondly, it's a fact that active members who are willing to join your loyalty club are many times more likely to participate in a ratings survey than those who don't.
If you're programming a radio station, ask yourself which is a better way to spend your budget:
A. Give every listener $1, or
B. Give each of your listeners who is carrying a people meter or filling out a diary $10.
If you chose A, we can't help you. If you chose B, wouldn't it follow that all of your offers would be directed to those who are willing to be a member of your club?
While each listener has a value, there are those who would never join your club, no matter the offer. Do you think those people would even take a phone call from a ratings service, let alone carrying the meter or filling out a diary? Really?
Use your assets to influence those that most influence on your success! Focus!


